| Article
What triggers violence in society
By THEA RUTHERFORD FN Features Editor
first published: http://freeport.nassauguardian.net/social_community/285266472586799.php
"You gat me sitting down in a cell for most of the
day. What I gat to lose?"
His searing question crackles like a lit fire-cracker with just minutes
until its inevitable explosion. It singes the walls and the mind, exacting
an answer from those who think that they have one. With burning pupils
and a voice that rasps questions and thunders their answers, Isaac, 50,
is every cell mate that he spent his two year sentence with at Her Majesty's
Prison, Fox Hill, before his release last September.
He is the needy little boy whose parents forgot to tell him that he was
special, that the world was his and that he could do anything he put his
mind to. He is the 15-year old half-hardened by the lack of expectations
society and his own parents have for him and even he has for himself.
Raped of any sliver of self-confidence long ago, at the age when all kids
feel that their dreams could only come true, his were suffocated by the
overwhelming feeling that nobody seemed to care. If they had, they had
never shown it, at least not in a way that he could be sure of.
As his voice gets louder, he grows into the young man who has tossed aside
books and school knowledge because it made no sense on the streets that
nurtured him when family didn't realise that their role was being usurped.
With the tip of that very first domino, everything else in his life would
fall, pushing against each other with an almost irreversible wind of hopelessness.
With the clink of the last domino, a once free man was behind bars.
"As a child gets older, moves out on the street, the best love and
attention or caring that they had probably was a bigger brother on the
streets who was probably selling drugs, making money and helping him to
buy a pants or shirt," Isaac explains. The first few chips fall.
Then incarceration.
"Society will knock you down as a teenager and wouldn't contribute
to the elevation of you achieving life skills and different vocational
training so that when they release you, you will have some type of avenue
to follow. But you end up right there on the streets and the only person
who'll help you on the streets is another brother who on the streets,"
he goes on. The collision course of dominoes continues.
With one more chip left standing, the choice seems easy, obvious even.
You can turn away from your burgeoning criminal career, but you have already
discarded your books and school and you never really learned to believe
in yourself. Suddenly your options seem dimmer than a lone light bulb
in a smoky room. Just like that, you are one shot, one armed robbery away
from becoming a recidivism statistic.
Even "if you want to stop your foolishness you are not qualified
for anything," says Isaac, speaking for the young men he observed
during his incarceration. "If you are not qualified for anything
but street life, what do you have to resort to?"
"I'll kill somebody"
It is easy to fire a weapon in a community that has no room for you. Violence,
an interpretation of human behaviour that is considered antisocial and
can be stimulated by a variety of things, says world-renowned teacher,
and prolific author, Dr. Myles Munroe, among other things, is a result
of the interaction of a human with his environment.
One of the reasons why violence increases in society is "because
people feel detached from a society. (They) feel isolated, not valued
by society," he says. "They feel the need to act in certain
ways to get attention.
"Sometimes people can be placed on the fringes of society by society
and so they react to being placed on the outside of society in negative
ways that they consider to be a way of getting attention or expressing
their anger at that society."
Violence can stem from the frustration of perceived societal exclusion
for one reason or another.
"Sources and causes of violence," Dr. Munroe says, "are
usually related to conditions in society that gravitate against a sense
of feeling integrated in that society. It is a result of people feeling
frustrated that they cannot participate in that society or they cannot
deliver what the society is demanding from them.
"If you don't educate a young group of people then you demand that
they act educated or that they perform activities that demand education,
you frustrate them. They respond to your demands with frustration that
results in violent activities."
In a world where a daily diet of violence in popular culture is eaten
up like popcorn at a movie theatre, it seems harder and harder to shock,
perturb or outrage. Images of violence take on a benign veneer in their
profusion. Talk of carnage becomes blasé. Another generation becomes
jaded and life soon seems as valueless as a crumpled paper cup.
Says clinical psychologist and school psychologist at the Ministry of
Education, Dr. Pamula Mills, "We're seeing children nowadays coming
forth (and) you ask them what would you do if you could change things
and they say, 'I'll kill somebody' - these things are starting from...
childhood in the homes."
A little society called 'home'
Largely products of their environment, children play out in their lives
what is modelled before them from their earliest memory and training.
Many experts agree that the first place of learning is in the home.
Although it can sometimes be attributed to genetic factors "violence
is learned behaviour," says Dr. Mills. "For the most part if
you have a violent community or a violent household then you have violent
kids."
While violence can result from a societal environment that does not make
people feel that they are important or that their contributions are valuable
to that community, violence itself is a sign that the first level of society
has failed, says Dr. Munroe.
"The first level of society is the home. "Every home is a small
society," says Dr. Munroe. "So when you fail in the home you'll
fail in society and so violence really begins in the home and violence
can only be solved in the home."
Having respect for your children and your household and setting a good
example for children in actions that speak volumes over words, sets the
pace in the home, expresses R.B.P.F. Assistant Commissioner, Ellison Greenslade.
"This is not an old story, it's not about being old-fashioned, it's
just about simple basic rules." Societal reform begins in the home.
"We go right back to this fundamental issue of how we are managing
our families. First and foremost how we manage ourselves how we manage
our families and are we demonstrating the level of concern. Are we showing
the appropriate amount of care, respect and trust to our children and
to our relatives," he questions. "Before we even step into the
wider arena of society we should ask those questions.
"This is very doable, I don't think that we are too far gone,"
says the senior law enforcement officer. "But it's going to have
to be done one family at a time. You're not going to wake up in The Bahamas
one morning and someone waves his magic wand and suddenly we've got it
right. It's not going to happen like that. There is no magical cure."
What there is, says Mr. Greenslade, is the basic tenet of love.
"Nurturing the human spirit"
If you don't hug your 15 year-old-son and tell him that you love him then,
Mr. Greenslade asks frankly, "who's going to tell him? At what age
do we stop hugging and kissing and affirming our sons," he says specifically
to men. "It takes a tremendous effort because you're so busy doing
everything else that you never stop and say to that child, 'I'm really
proud of you,' looking him in the eye, put your arms on him and touch
him because people like to be touched, hugged and nurtured.
"There must be something to be said about nurturing the human spirit."
Failing to affirm children in the home can make them a lot more vulnerable
to what lurks outside its safe walls. "I prefer to tell them in the
house," says Mr. Greenslade of affirming children, "than to
have someone tell them in the street and steal my kid from me."
In over 24 years of observations in his field of law enforcement, Mr.
Greenslade chalks reform all up to nurturing the human spirit - taking
care of each other, communicating, showing affection and resolving our
differences peacefully. "Where love exists violence can't,"
he says.
Purpose leads to discipline - the opposite of violence
"If you don't understand the purpose of a thing you will abuse it,"
says Dr. Munroe quoting one of his favourite lines in his book on the
subject.
"A person who participates in antisocial behaviour with no regard
for law and order is a person who has not (discovered) the contribution
that he is supposed to make to building society. So the most important
thing that anyone can discover in life to prevent them from being a negative
component of society is their purpose."
Purpose, he defines, is the original reason for your existence. It is
discovering why you were born, the meaning for your life.
"When a person captures that, suddenly everything in life becomes
important. If you feel that you are not important or valuable, everything
else feels that way. If you feel that you are important, you treat everybody
else that way." When a person discovers their purpose they discover
discipline, says Dr. Munroe. And "discipline is the opposite of violence."
Conflict resolution,
without the guns
Recent events of senseless acts of violence that dominate the news not
only shed a blood-tinged light on an apparent lack of value for life,
but an inability or refusal to find ways of peacefully resolving conflicts.
Dr. Mills calls the failure to resolve conflicts calmly one of the biggest
contributors to violence in society.
"People don't know how to resolve conflicts amicably and because
of that instead of talking things through... people are resorting to confronting
people in a physical manner that may sometimes lead to death."
Will your children learn to solve conflicts the same way that you do?
There is a good chance that they might. Says Dr. Mills, we don't understand
the affect that constant fighting and arguing to resolve conflicts can
have on the smallest child.
"We're not stopping to talk to one another, everybody has pent up
emotions," says the psychologist.
Dr. Mills admits that there are other societal stressors that can lead
to frustration that can in turn breed violence. High rates of unemployment,
post-traumatic stress from the string of hurricanes, mass tragedy are
all among them.
"When you add all of these things together, people are just not thinking
very clearly and instead of sitting down and trying to get themselves
together, they're just acting on impulse." Yet such spur of the moment
induced violence can be replaced with conflict resolution.
"It's a nationwide thing and in lieu of the (prison break) we really
need to get on the ball in dealing with conflict resolution. We really
need to tell people you have to stop and take some introspection,"
she says. The psychologist has pledged to embark on this better way in
the schools with conflict resolution classes she hopes to begin this year.
The resolution of violence in society lies within the grasp of all of
its citizens. Active citizenship - citizenship where individuals take
an active role in community building and own up to personal responsibility
- is one large step towards the goal, Mr. Greenslade demonstrates.
He is thrilled with the new and improved relationship that he says that
many of his officers now have with people in the community who have chosen
to play such an active role.
"The appeal must be for citizens all over The Bahamas (to exercise)
responsible citizenship," says the Assistant Commissioner. "You
must take an active role in community building, an active role in ensuring
that The Bahamas is safe and secure for all of us."
Education
While the present education system that emphasizes the academics so necessary
for success in the job world is good, Dr. Munroe believes that as a revision
of the system to focus on "rediscovering self, self worth and self
esteem" is more crucial.
"If we build these things first then academic education has a meaning,"
he explains. "Once we get meaning in our lives then we will see violence
subside."
Convinced that the H.M.P compound is an incubator for breeding more hardened
criminals, Isaac feels that a regularised system of work should be made
mandatory and that inmates should be taught vocational skills on its premises.
Harsher measures behind its walls, he says, are not the answer. What happens
when the prisoners become immune to such measures, he questions.
"If these people adapt and adjust to (harsher measures), the tougher
they get." The mental hardening, he says, leads to lack of value
for life and violence on the outside.
"Put something in these people hands what they could lose, what they're
going to feel," says Isaac of education. "Give them training
that they wouldn't want to let go," he says noting that his own qualifications
are his strength and work that he depended on after his release.
If things remain the same, Isaac fears of societal attitudes towards inmates
in and out of prison, "you creating that monster."
Comments: We are often asked
to comment on the causes of violence and there are many ways to answer
this question. The writer of this article that recently appeared in The
Freeport News, looks at what the experts say, not only those who are trained
to work with prisoners who have ended up incarcerated but also with the
prisoners themselves. One thing is so clear, that punishment itself merely
holds on to the problem and makes it worse over time. When you lock somebody
up to punish them and you give them no possibility of improvement, they
feel they have nothing to lose. You might suggest they have lost something
very important, and that thing is freedom. But you would be wrong. They
were in prison long before they got locked up and unless we begin to understand
and care for people who commit crimes, we will only need to build more
and more prisons. Why do we want to maintain misery and suffering? Why
is there so little need in a society that is almost 80% Christian (CIA
factbook, 2002) to love our neighbour as ourselves? This article makes
some valid suggestions to bring us out of the dark cave we have chosen
and into some light.
-Brian
Related articles:
The World Biggest Hidden Secret:
Childhood Abuse and its Effects
By Sieglinde W. Alexander
Open Letter to: Governor
Bill Richardson
Sieglinde W. Alexander
|